Straddle Carrier vs Gantry Crane: Which One is Right for Your Project?

When it comes to heavy lifting and load transportation, two popular equipment types often come up: the straddle carrier and the gantry crane. Both are powerful tools, but they serve different purposes depending on your site conditions, load types, and mobility requirements.

In this article, we’ll compare straddle carriers and gantry cranes across key factors to help you choose the right solution.

♣ What is a Straddle Carrier?

A straddle carrier is a self-propelled mobile crane that lifts and transports loads by straddling them. It doesn’t require rails or a fixed foundation, making it ideal for modular buildings, steel trusses, and containers.

🔧 Typical Use Cases:

♠ Moving long steel beams or pipes

♠ Transporting modular building components

♠ Handling shipping containers in yards

♠ Prefabricated concrete structure lifting

♣ What is a Gantry Crane?

A gantry crane is a lifting system that runs along fixed rails or wheels. It consists of a horizontal beam supported by two legs, and often uses an electric hoist or trolley to lift loads. Gantry cranes are common in factories, workshops, and shipyards.

🔧 Typical Use Cases:

♠ Indoor material handling

♠ Maintenance operations

♠ Mold and die lifting in workshops

♠ Yard loading/unloading

♣ Key Differences: Straddle Carrier vs Gantry Crane

♣ When to Choose a Straddle Carrier？

✅ You need to lift and move long or oversized components (like 30m steel trusses)
✅ Your site changes often and needs mobility
✅ You don’t have space or budget for permanent rails
✅ You’re handling modular buildings, containers, or steel structures

♣ When to Choose a Gantry Crane

✅ You work indoors with fixed operations
✅ Your loads are regular in shape and weight
✅ You need precise vertical lifting
✅ You have space for rails or tracks

♣ Which One is More Cost-Effective?

♠ Initial Cost: Gantry cranes are typically cheaper, especially for small loads (≤10 tons)

♠ Flexibility & ROI: Straddle carriers offer better return for large, changing projects where load sizes and locations vary

♣ Final Recommendation

If your project involves modular, long, or heavy components, and you need mobility, a straddle carrier is your best choice.

If your operations are fixed, repetitive, and indoors, then a gantry crane will get the job done with lower upfront investment.

Need Help Choosing?

Still unsure? Contact MOT Cranes for a custom consultation.
📩 Get a Free Quote
📞 [Email: sales@motcrane.com]